• Home
  • Books
  • Blog
  • About
  • Podcasts, TV, Interviews & More
  • Media Kit
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Heather Day Gilbert

Author

Guest Blogger–CREEPY QUERY GIRL Talks Queries!

My guest blogger today never ceases to amuse AND inform me with her blogposts. I started following her when I was in the depths of my querying despair, because her blog-name said it all: “Creepy Query Girl” (aren’t we all, at some point or another!). You can find her over at http://creepyquerygirl.blogspot.com/. Her real name is Katie Mills, and here’s how she describes herself:

I used to be a normal married mother of three. Then I finished my first book and slowly transformed into the creepy query girl. Now in my spare time I’m tracking literary agents’ every move. On the internet. Not like, outside their windows with binoculars…yet.

The Creepy Query Girl Talks Queries…
 
So, when Heather first asked me to do a guest post talking about ‘the query letter’- I realized that in the last two years as the ‘Creepy Query Girl’, I had not once written a blog post explaining how to write a successful query letter.
I guess it’s because there are SO many awesome resources out there. (Like query queen Elana Johnson’s ‘Writing a Query Letter’ Series–http://elanajohnson.blogspot.com/p/writing-query-letter.html or Matt MacNish’s weekly query workshops–http://theqqqe.blogspot.com/)–I didn’t think anybody would really want my two cents on the matter.
But the truth is, you might think your publishing journey begins the moment you finish your first book (poem, short story, article, etc…) but in reality- it all begins with the query.  It’s your first contact with the world of publishing- the first time you’ll be representing who you are and what you have to say to the industry professionals that could make it all happen!  (daunting much?) There are a million resources out there that give you the ‘right way’ to write a query. Some agency websites even give you their own version of what they’d like to see. But the basic formula is:
Greeting (Be agent-specific. No ‘Dear Agent’ or ‘Dear Agency’ greetings.  Agents like to know you’ve queried them based on their sales, preferred genre, and experience. Not because their name was the first one in an alphabetized list.)
Hook (The aspect of your story most likely to catch the agents interest.)
Premise (main conflict, what’s at stake, and character information)
Basic info(genre, word count, target audience and any credentials you might have)
Close (The full manuscript is available upon request/ Thank you for your time/ peace out:)
But what determines a successful query, you ask?  – Um-requests. (duh duh duh!) Truth is, you could follow the query formula to a ‘T’ but if it isn’t garnering requests from agents or editors to see an excerpt of the book- it isn’t doing its job.
My tips for making sure your query is representing your book to the best of its ability:
The voice. You want to make sure that the way you deliver your hook and premise also reflect the tone of your book and the personality of your main character.  Is it a funny story? Snarky? Bittersweet? Chuck-full of mystery and foreboding? – Well that’s the kind of tone you want to use in your query.
Keep it short n’ sweet.– Get right to the point. Make sure your conflict and what’s at stake should your main character ‘fail’ are clear and concise. You don’t need to include every little detail or a complete plot summary. Save that for the synopsis (should they ask for one).
If you don’t have any writing credentials- don’t try to compensate by giving the agent a run-down of who you are, where you’re from, your age and occupation.  If you aren’t JK Rowling of Scotland- they probably won’t care much.  
I do, however, think it’s okay to mention your blog. It shows agents that you’ve done your homework, are serious about becoming a published author, and are capable of maintaining a writer’s platform.
Once your query starts garnering requests, you’ve got one foot in the door!
Next all you have to worry about is whether or not your full or partial manuscript is right’n’ready for said agent. (but that’s a whole other can of worms:)
So glad to be invited over here Heather!  I’m happy to answer any questions or comments in the comment section below!
Katie (aka CQG:)

Thank you, Katie! 

****Have you ever made any major query mistakes? I know I have! Please share some of your query wisdom or share your questions with the Creepy Query Girl!****

Share
Pin
Email
Print


Creepy Query Girl// Katie Mills// querying

« Newbie Writing Mistakes Monday–TAKING CRITICISM
Newbie Writing Mistakes Monday–KEEP TRACK OF QUERIES! »

Comments

  1. Heather Day Gilbert says

    March 16, 2012 at 2:22 pm

    Thanks so much for blogging today, Katie! And my first query was just something I threw together–a regular fiasco. Thankfully, I had a friend read over it and give me some massive editing tips. We polished it up till it hooked you right in. Only problem was, my book was too short and it was a little edgy for Christian fiction. But I did (finally!) get some requests!

  2. TC Avey says

    March 16, 2012 at 3:57 pm

    Thanks Katie.My query is evolving. Looking back, I can see it has transformed (though only time will tell what it has finally morphed into). I just started re-sending it and am hoping/praying I will finally get something other than the standard "this isn't a good fit for us" rejection letter.

  3. Creepy Query Girl says

    March 16, 2012 at 6:56 pm

    Thanks Heather! Querying definitely has its ups and downs- even with a great query. All we can do is keep trying and keep sending things out! Congrats on your requests!

  4. Heather Day Gilbert says

    March 16, 2012 at 8:25 pm

    It was actually great practice for the next query (for my next book!), which finally (after other requests) found its way into the hands of my most awesome agent! Every query is a step toward figuring out what works best, like you say, Katie!

  5. Amy L. Sonnichsen says

    March 16, 2012 at 10:49 pm

    Great post, Katie! And I love the new blog look, Heather. Very professional. I may need your help one of these days to revamp mine. Oi. Query mistakes … hmmm … I'm pretty sure my first two query letters were atrocious, but I think it's especially hard to write a query when the plot of your book is suspect (which was my big problem with the first two books). Queries really do help you decide whether you have something Awesome or something Flawed. This was a lesson I learned the hard way!

  6. Andy Scheer says

    March 16, 2012 at 10:52 pm

    If your query is to an agent, make sure you say your proposal is ready (and that your book is complete.

  7. Heather Day Gilbert says

    March 17, 2012 at 12:17 am

    Thank you, Amy! That gives me an idea for a guest blogpost about setting up cool blogs. And if plot's lacking, it's sad to see it once you're sitting down to write that query, for sure.And yes, it's great to have a proposal ready to go if it's requested (proposals need a blogpost all their own!). Also important to get that word count in there and say it's complete. Thanks for the input, Andy!

  8. Sarah Pearson says

    March 18, 2012 at 3:40 pm

    Excellent, informative post. How would you mention your blog in the query, (assuming you don't have anything else to sandwich it in between that an agent would be interested in)?

  9. Heather Day Gilbert says

    March 18, 2012 at 5:51 pm

    Sarah, that's a good question! I think you can't go wrong putting it under your name (along w/twitter info, etc), unless it's incredibly successful, garnering a notable number of hits/comments/followers, in which case, definitely mention that in the letter. I know when I first started a blog and mentioned it in one of my queries, a top agent was happy to let me know that wasn't even relevant info for a wannabe debut author.BUT times have changed since then, and I would also think that any online presence info you could include would be helpful. But that might be more for the proposal, as opposed to the query.Any recent query-ers have any info on protocol for blog info in the letter?

  10. Creepy Query Girl says

    March 18, 2012 at 5:52 pm

    Sarah- I usually stick it in there at the end with the 'In addition to novels, I also write articles about publishing, the craft of writing, and the querying process which are featured on my blog- Creepy Query Girl.'

  11. Heather Day Gilbert says

    March 18, 2012 at 11:33 pm

    Yes, what Creepy Query Girl said! That sounds good! It's true, you put so much effort into a blog, you should be able to mention it.

Hi, I’m Heather…

I write contemporary mysteries and Viking historicals. Born and brought up in the mountains of West Virginia, I enjoy writing about small towns, family relationships, and women who aren't afraid to protect those they love. Read More…

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • BookBub
  • Goodreads

Join Me on Instagram

Anyone else feel the bulb catalogues target us whe Anyone else feel the bulb catalogues target us when everything is looking so dead and blah? I have some daffodils and scrappy looking tulip leaves emerging but here’s hoping the snow season ends soon. ❄️☕️❄️#flowersofinstagram #flowerlovers🌸♥️ #springflowers🌸 #authorlife
Had a wonderful time this weekend speaking on an a Had a wonderful time this weekend speaking on an author panel @bjuedu with authors Jamie Langston Turner and Emily Golus (@worldofvindor) with @inkwellmagazine. What a wealth of experience these talented authors brought to the table for the guests and writers who attended! Also met author @louannkeisereditor, who was a delight to speak with. Then got to hang out with my lifelong friend @rachelcohee and her husband and daughter and brunch @grandbohemianlodgegreenville at the Between the Trees restaurant. Then capped things off at a bookstore that was hopping! What a much-needed time of relaxation with my husband, who graciously schleps my book boxes and takes event photos for me!📚#authorlife #wvauthor
All 10 covers of my Barks & Beans Cafe #cozymyster All 10 covers of my Barks & Beans Cafe #cozymysteries—how many have you read? These are books 1-9 and my standalone novella House Blend. If you love #shelterdogs, coffee, and #mystery, check out this small-town series set in #lewisburgwv! 🐶☕️📚 #cozymysteryseries
One more day on sale for 99c/Kindle! 3-book boxed One more day on sale for 99c/Kindle! 3-book boxed set of fan favorite #Christianmysteries featuring #amateursleuth Tess Spencer 📚☕️Check out the Murder in the Mountains set on Amazon now! #wvwritersworkshop #wildandwonderfulwv #wvmountainmama
Follow on Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • X
  • YouTube
  • Goodreads
  • Home
  • Books
  • Blog
  • About
  • Podcasts, TV, Interviews & More
  • Media Kit
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2026 · Heather Day Gilbert · All Rights Reserved · Privacy Policy