• Home
  • Books
  • Blog
  • About
  • Podcasts, TV, Interviews & More
  • Media Kit
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Heather Day Gilbert

Author

On Rejection and My Attempts to Deal With It

After a stellar and astonishing week, when no less than FOUR agents were requesting my sample chapters/pages, and my children and husband would attest that my happiness was through the roof, I have had a letdown, reject week of almost equal proportions. Two of the bigger historical fiction agents rejected my book, leaving me once again questioning my skill (or lack of it) in writing.

I do realize that Kathryn Stockett’s “The Help,” as well as J.K. Rowling, John Grisham, etc. have met with numerous rejections before publication. They did not give up. But then I am reminded of Stephenie Meyer, who maybe had 14 rejections. I’ve probably reached that number (between my two novels), so in my mind, if I can’t beat Stephenie Meyer, I’m useless. Okay, maybe not QUITE that bad, but I am competitive, you know. Mostly with myself.

And so, I begin to think that maybe this blog was a bad idea, especially if I have to take it down, hanging my head in shame. “I can’t write, why did I ever think I could?” keeps running through my mind. I know you all believe in me, and many of you have offered encouragement on Facebook and elsewhere. However, I have to determine in myself if it is worthwhile to continue pouring months into these writing endeavors, only to have no one read my book. E-books are tempting, but I do want a hard copy of the book in the end.

I love to write, and even now I walk around with new ideas for books about every day. Once you’re locked in the writing mode, it’s hard to get your brain out. However, this does not bode well for a home-schooler who needs to teach her children all the stuff they need to know before college!

So, I have concluded that for now I am taking a break. Maybe I’m not quitting. Maybe I’m just recuperating. I still have queries out, and I may still get bites. I’m still trying to keep some faith. I hope my next post will be one of jubilation, where I have found the agent who really “gets” my books. I just gotta know that what I’m fighting for is worth it! If it is, I’ll come back swinging, and if it’s not, I’m willing to concede defeat. Well, at least I think so.

–Heather

Share
Pin
Email
Print


agent// querying// rejection// Stephenie Meyer

« Just a Taste
Have Your Cake and Eat It, Too »

Comments

  1. Perri says

    August 9, 2011 at 10:04 pm

    Hang in there, Heather! In my (limited) experience, a few days really helps me to gain perspective. Your novel just needs to "click" with one agent. The requests tell you your query and writing are solid. I am at the same point with my querying/waiting/hoping/bumming, and can say with certainty that taking a break, playing with the kids, walking the beach really helps. Then come back to your manuscript, brush it up, and send it back out

  2. Heather says

    August 12, 2011 at 1:32 pm

    Thanks so much for your words of wisdom, Perri! And I'm back to querying and polishing. I've decided if this is my passion, I might as well do it!

Hi, I’m Heather…

I write contemporary mysteries and Viking historicals. Born and brought up in the mountains of West Virginia, I enjoy writing about small towns, family relationships, and women who aren't afraid to protect those they love. Read More…

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • BookBub
  • Goodreads

Join Me on Instagram

So pleased that @jaimejowright thought my upcoming So pleased that @jaimejowright thought my upcoming #cozy-mystery ALL THE SUSPECTS ON CAMPUS was worthy of ā€œtwo knives up!ā€ Read her endorsement below, and preorder now! This #AgathaChristie #bookclub mystery will release in January 2027!
***SUMMER SALE ALERT!*** Pick up the bestselling 3 ***SUMMER SALE ALERT!*** Pick up the bestselling 3-book #BarksandBeansCafe #cozymysteries for only 99c/Kindle, now through July 3! Meet the sibling sleuths who run a cafe where folks can pet #shelterdogs…and where murder sometimes pays a visit. #amazonbooksšŸ“š #wvauthor
Now through June 26, you can preorder my upcoming Now through June 26, you can preorder my upcoming (Jan 2027) #cozymystery ALL THE SUSPECTS ON CAMPUS for a 25% discount if you’re a premium/rewards member at  #barnesandnoble. Just enter discount code PREORDER25! #bookstagram #mystery
Happy #WestVirginiaDay! You might know that I love Happy #WestVirginiaDay! You might know that I love setting my contemporary mystery series in my home state of WV. What you might not know is that there was a time I wanted nothing more than to move away and spread my wings (somewhere like NYC! Where I wound up living for a year when I got married!). But years down the road, I felt my mountain roots pulling me back. Suddenly, I could see nothing but beauty in these comforting mountains and moody skies and honeysuckled summers. West Virginia is so many things—good and bad as any state is—but it’s entirely unique. My husband once marveled at how many people ā€œcame backā€ to their home state here, even after being gone for years, and I see that all the time. These #Appalachianmountains have a way about them, and it becomes a part of you, a love you don’t want to let go of. I’m a #mountainmama, and I’m glad to bring this truly #wildandwonderful state to readers with my books.
Follow on Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • X
  • YouTube
  • Goodreads
  • Home
  • Books
  • Blog
  • About
  • Podcasts, TV, Interviews & More
  • Media Kit
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2026 Ā· Heather Day Gilbert Ā· All Rights Reserved Ā· Privacy Policy